Skip to main content

Robotic surgery concerns

While the da Vinci's success story continues (according to Intuitive, they've reached 90% penetration in LRP in the USA), and even the President played around with it, many people expressed their concerns about the economic and patient benefits.
Primary concern is the price of the device, where not even the initial 0.75-2 M USD is really a hit, but the maintenance and tool costs.

NY Times featured an article some time ago, citing the JAMA study (previously criticized here) to emphasis the lack of clinical benefits. (Medgadget also covered the story.)

A recent publication in the Journal of Urology found that despite the popularity of robot-assisted procedures for prostate cancer, when it comes to men's long-term quality of life, patients with earlier stage cancers generally fare better with non-surgical approaches than with surgery.

Others questioned the use of the robot with heart procedures (Are Robotics a Good Idea for Cardiac Surgeons? by Chad Sumulong), while they admit, trends lead towards robotic surgery.
ConsultantLive wrote about the surgery-versus-chemoradiotherapy debate surrounding the evidences whether robotic surgery offers oncologic outcomes comparable to chemoradiation. Interestingly, they cite the same article that was written by the group who pushed the whole procedure through the FDA. Other studies are in favor of the robotic head-and-neck procedures.
After all, the numbers clearly show the success of the marketing and Intuitive, leaving the throne of the da Vinci unthreatened.

Update: Patient complications not the fault of robot, says WDH surgeon
- Study Finds Robotics Not Always Best For Hysterectomy Success And Recovery
- Endometriosis? Robotic surgery may not be the answer

Comments

worldofurology said…
Robotic cancer surgery by a trained urologist at the World of Urology clinic is at par with international standards. It is a minimally invasive surgery where surgeons use a computer-controlled robot to assist them.
worldofurology said…
Various disorders, including cancers of the bladder, kidney, and prostate, as well as other non-cancer problems of these organs, are treated in an efficient and successful mannerrobotic surgery in urologyOur physicians at the World of Urology perform these procedures using the robotic system tool, preventing damage to adjacent nerves and hastening recovery.
worldofurology said…
The most frequent times that renal tumors are found are through physical examinations or when a patient is seen for another condition and tests are run. Is Robotic Prostate Surgery Better Top doctors at the World of Urology help understand individuals understand why is robotic prostate surgery better to remove prostate cancer.
worldofurology said…
Robotic-assisted radical prostatectomy patients have less blood loss, less pain, shorter hospital stays, and quicker recovery times. Is Robotic Prostate Surgery Better We at the World of Urology are well equipped this surgery and hence optimum choice to provide answer for your quation of is robotic prostate surgery better.
worldofurology said…
Many of the drawbacks of traditional laparoscopy have been overcome by robot-assisted surgery World Of Urology You can connect with Doctors of the World of Urology for a robotic assisted kidney transplant in bangalore
worldofurology said…
Leading nephrologists and surgeons from the World of Urology collaborate to come up with the finest treatment choices for any kidney-related problem. kidney specialist in bangalore Our top kidney specialist in bangalore has extensive knowledge and experience using modern medical technologies to treat a variety of kidney disorders.
worldofurology said…
A novel approach to urological surgical treatments is robotic urology surgery in Bangalore. Robotic Urology Surgery In Bangalore The first city in India to provide this novel method is Bangalore, and WorldofUrology is pleased to be at the forefront of bringing this cutting-edge surgical alternative to India.
worldofurology said…
The world of urology is a fascinating field of medicine and science dedicated to diagnosing, treating, and preventing diseases of the urinary tract and male reproductive organs. world of urology treating prostate cancer, urologists are specially trained to provide the best patient care. The team at Worldofurology stands ready to offer comprehensive and evidence-based urology care with a focus on quality, safety, and efficacy.
worldofurology said…
Trust World of Urology's commitment to innovation and expert care as we continue to redefine urogynecological treatments through robotic-assisted hysterectomy. robotic assisted hysterectomy The treatment offers patients numerous benefits, including minimal invasiveness, faster recovery, and reduced discomfort. Led by skilled urogynecologists
worldofurology said…
Welcome to the World of Urology - Your Trusted Source for Expert Insights! We strive to deliver cutting-edge information on urological health, advancements, and treatments. Empowering individuals to make informed decisions for a healthier future is our mission.
worldofurology said…
Dr. Mohan Keshavamurthy stands out as the best urologist in Bangalore, revered for exceptional expertise and compassionate care. Their commitment to patient well-being and remarkable surgical skills solidify their position as the best urologist in India.
worldofurology said…
Is robotic prostate surgery better? Find answers at World of Urology. Explore the benefits of advanced robotic techniques for prostate surgery. Trust World of Urology to help you make informed decisions about your health.
worldofurology said…
At World of Urology, you can find Bangalore's Best Urology doctor in Bangalore. Our eminent urologists are known for their knowledge,. best urology doctor in bangalore Whether you need routine check-ups or complicated operations, you can rely on World of Urology for excellent urological care. Your health is our main priority
worldofurology said…
Enter the World of Urology We're dedicated to advancing urological health, providing expert insights, and connecting you with top urologists. Explore our comprehensive resources and stay informed about the latest developments in urology.
worldofurology said…
Discover state-of-the-art technology at World of Urology with robotic cancer surgery. Our cutting-edge techniques provide accurate robotic cancer surgery least intrusive cancer therapy options. Our skilled staff uses the most advanced robotic equipment available to guarantee unmatched accuracy,
worldofurology said…
At the World of Urology in Bangalore, our goal is to provide cancer patients with the best robotic cancer surgery available. With a high degree of integrity, compliance, and disciplinerobotic cancer surgery this method enables our surgeons to carry out complex procedures. Their impressive abilities and background are sure to benefit the patients.
worldofurology said…
Explore the cutting-edge realm of robotic cancer surgery with World of Urology. Revolutionizing treatment, robotic procedures offer precision and minimal invasiveness robotic cancer surgerydelve into advanced techniques, empowering patients and practitioners alike in the fight against urological cancers

Popular Posts